How to Challenge an Arbitrator Under Sections 12 to 15


Quick answer: A party can challenge an arbitrator under Section 12 if circumstances give rise to justifiable doubts about independence or impartiality, or the agreed qualifications are missing. Unless the parties agree a procedure, the challenge goes to the tribunal in writing within 15 days of becoming aware. If it fails, the tribunal continues and the party may challenge the award under Section 34.

A challenge to an arbitrator is a serious step. Done well, it protects the fairness of the process. Done badly or too late, it wastes time, adds cost and may harden the other side. The Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 sets out the grounds and the procedure in Sections 12 to 15, and the time limits are short.

This guide explains who can challenge, on what grounds, within what time, and what happens afterwards. It also explains the separate court route under Section 14 for arbitrators who cannot or do not act.

What are the grounds for challenge?

Section 12(3) allows a challenge on two grounds. The first is that there are circumstances giving rise to justifiable doubts about the arbitrator's independence or impartiality. The second is that the arbitrator does not have the qualifications the parties agreed in the contract.

Section 12(4) adds a limit. A party who appointed or took part in appointing an arbitrator can challenge that person only for reasons the party became aware of after the appointment. This protects the process from parties who accept an arbitrator and then change their mind.

Our earlier guide on arbitrator independence and the Fifth and Seventh Schedules lists the circumstances that commonly raise doubts.

What is the challenge procedure under Section 13?

  1. Check whether the contract or institutional rules set a procedure. If they do, follow it.
  2. If they do not, send a written statement of the reasons for the challenge to the tribunal within 15 days of becoming aware of the tribunal's constitution or of the circumstance.
  3. The challenged arbitrator may withdraw, or the other party may agree to the challenge. If neither happens, the tribunal decides the challenge.
  4. If the challenge succeeds, the arbitrator's mandate ends and a substitute is appointed under Section 15.
  5. If the challenge fails, the tribunal continues and makes the award.

The 15-day period is short. Start collecting facts and drafting the statement as soon as you learn of the issue.

What happens if the challenge fails?

Section 13(4) says that if the challenge is not successful, the tribunal continues the proceedings and makes the award. Section 13(5) says the challenging party may then apply to set aside the award under Section 34. The court will examine the challenge as part of that application.

In effect, a failed challenge keeps your objection alive, but you must continue to take part in the arbitration. Do not walk out. Keep your objection on record and plan the Section 34 application as a possible next step.

Info - How to Challenge an Arbitrator Under Sections 12 to 15


When can you go to court under Section 14?

Section 14 deals with a different situation. An arbitrator's mandate ends if the arbitrator becomes unable to perform the functions in law or in fact, or fails to act without undue delay, and either withdraws or the parties agree to end the mandate. If there is a dispute on any of these grounds, a party may apply to the court to decide whether the mandate has ended.

The Supreme Court has explained that a person who is ineligible under Section 12(5) is treated as unable to perform the functions, so the court route under Section 14 applies. You do not have to wait for the Section 13 procedure in that case. A ruling on ineligibility is therefore usually sought directly from the court.

What does Section 15 provide after termination?

Where an arbitrator's mandate ends, a substitute is appointed using the same rules that applied to the original appointment. Unless the parties agree otherwise, the reconstituted tribunal may repeat earlier hearings at its discretion, and earlier orders are not invalid only because the composition of the tribunal changed. The Act also allows the mandate to end by agreement of the parties or by withdrawal.

This is why a challenge can cause delay. The new arbitrator needs time to read the record, and hearings may be repeated. Weigh the benefit of the challenge against the delay and cost.

Which route applies to your situation?

SituationRouteTime or forum
Doubts about independence or impartialityChallenge under Section 13Written statement to the tribunal within 15 days
Arbitrator lacks agreed qualificationsChallenge under Section 13Same 15-day period
Arbitrator ineligible under Section 12(5)Apply to the court under Section 14Court of competent jurisdiction, with prompt filing
Arbitrator unable to act or fails to act with due speedApply under Section 14 if there is a disputeCourt of competent jurisdiction
Challenge failed and the award is madeSection 34 applicationWithin 3 months of the award, plus 30 days if sufficient cause

Practical tips for a clean challenge

  • Act quickly. Delay can be read as acceptance.
  • Put your objection in writing and give specific facts, not suspicion.
  • Attach proof, such as disclosures, websites, emails or filings.
  • Keep taking part in the proceedings under protest if the challenge is refused.
  • Think about how the timeline interacts with the 12-month award period in Section 29A, which we explain later in this series.

For an overview of hearings and procedure, read how to prepare for an arbitration hearing and arbitrator powers to terminate proceedings.

Key takeaways

  • Grounds: justifiable doubts about independence or impartiality, or missing agreed qualifications.
  • Unless agreed otherwise, the written challenge must reach the tribunal within 15 days.
  • If the challenge fails, the tribunal continues and you may apply under Section 34 after the award.
  • Section 14 covers arbitrators who cannot or do not act, and is the route for ineligibility.
  • A substitute is appointed under Section 15, and hearings may be repeated.

Frequently asked questions

What is the time limit to challenge an arbitrator?

Unless the parties agree a different procedure, Section 13(2) requires a written statement of reasons to be sent to the tribunal within 15 days of becoming aware of the constitution of the tribunal or of the circumstance that gives rise to the challenge.

Who decides the challenge?

Under Section 13(3), the arbitral tribunal decides, unless the challenged arbitrator withdraws or the other party agrees to the challenge. If the challenge fails, the proceedings continue and the objection can be raised again in a Section 34 application.

Can I challenge the arbitrator that I appointed?

Only for reasons that you became aware of after the appointment. Section 12(4) limits a challenge by a party who appointed or took part in appointing the arbitrator, to prevent a change of mind without new facts.

What if the arbitrator is ineligible under the Seventh Schedule?

The Supreme Court has treated such a person as unable to perform the functions, so the court route under Section 14 is available. You do not have to follow the Section 13 procedure first. Raise it promptly and avoid any conduct that may look like a waiver.

What happens when an arbitrator is replaced?

A substitute is appointed under Section 15, following the rules that applied to the original appointment. Unless the parties agree, the new tribunal decides whether to repeat hearings, so expect some delay.

Should I continue in the arbitration while the challenge is pending?

Yes, unless the tribunal stops. If the challenge is rejected, Section 13(4) lets the tribunal continue and make the award. Keep your objection on record and plan a Section 34 application if the issue still matters.

Need advice on an arbitration matter? Apex Law House advises on arbitration, interim relief, award challenges and enforcement. Write to rajendralawoffice@gmail.com or call +91-9444014096.

Sources and references

Disclaimer: this article is general information on Indian arbitration law and is not legal advice. Laws and judgments change, so please verify the current position and take professional advice for your facts.

Last reviewed: October 2026.